Creative City Developments | Rhinelander, WI

Salem 91·Park City 90·Leavenworth 89·St. George 84·Alexandria 80·Bozeman 79·New Glarus 77·Billings 75·Medora 74·Detroit Lakes 73·Bentonville 71·Cedar City 67·Mackinac 66·Pella 64·Glenwood 60·Anoka 49·Salem 91·Park City 90·Leavenworth 89·St. George 84·Alexandria 80·Bozeman 79·New Glarus 77·Billings 75·Medora 74·Detroit Lakes 73·Bentonville 71·Cedar City 67·Mackinac 66·Pella 64·Glenwood 60·Anoka 49·
Wisconsin

Rhinelander, WI

Population: 7,798

Towns  /  Rhinelander, WI  /  Case Study
0

On the Map

Visitor Impact Score
67D+/ 100
composite

Online tier, provisional until field audit

On the Map. Rhinelander is a small Wisconsin lumber town that turned a 19th century monster hoax into a durable civic brand, and it now sits inside a county pulling hundreds of millions in visitor spending, but its physical anchor and stay experience still lag the strength of its story.

The VIS card at a glance

Pop. 7,798 (2020 Census), Wisconsin. U is the Unique Hook multiplier, then seven components. Framework VIS v1.0, online tier.

Category Name Grade Score
U UNIQUE HOOK multiplier 1.17x
W WEB B 83
B BRAND A- 91
A ANCHOR F 37
D DOWNTOWN n/a n/a
C CURB n/a n/a
S STAY D 61
R RETURN D 63
Category scores, VIS v1.0
W Web & Digital Presence
B Brand Identity
A Anchor Activity
S Stay & Itinerary
R Return & Referral
Fix first
Convert the brand into a bookable anchor

Rhinelander scores an F on Anchor Activity while its Brand Identity lands near the top of the corpus. The Hodag is beloved and everywhere, yet there is no single ticketed, dependable, year round Hodag attraction to build a visit around. Package the statue, murals, and the Pioneer Park story into one clear anchor experience visitors can plan and pay for.

Capture the town from the surrounding county economy

Oneida County brings in hundreds of millions in tourism and it is on the rise, but tourism statistics on Rhinelander itself are thin. Rhinelander is the largest of the three main towns in the area, so it should be measuring and marketing its own share of that county spend rather than letting the number stay a county wide figure.

Deepen the stay and return experience

Stay and Itinerary sits at 61 and Return and Referral at 63, both soft. The outdoor menu is strong year round, from hiking, camping, boating, canoeing, and bird watching in summer to cross country skiing, snowshoeing, and snowmobiling in winter. Tie those activities to overnight itineraries and repeat visit hooks so a Hodag day trip becomes a Hodag weekend.

/01 / The story

How Rhinelander earned the score

Population 7,798 (US Census 2020)

Situation A lumber town on the Wisconsin River faced decline as the mill economy that founded it faded.

Action Built a funky civic identity around the Hodag, a mythical monster invented in the 1890s, naming businesses, parks, and events after it.

Result Oneida County, where Rhinelander is the largest town, draws 237 million in tourism spending and the figure is on the rise.

Rhinelander, Wisconsin tourism photo featured in a Creative City Developments case study: Hodag statue
Rhinelander field photo, archive image

Let’s Meet Rhinelander, Wisconsin

History

Rhinelander was first conceptualized and created as a lumber town since it sits on the banks of the Wisconsin River. Brown’s vision of Rhinelander being a lumber town did not come to fruition for some years. Anderson Brown managed to convince their father and uncle to purchase the land from the federal government and build a town. The city was named Rhinelander after Frederic W. Rhinelander of New York, who was president of the Milwaukee, Lake Shore and Western Railroad at the time. Unsurprisingly, in 1882, the railroad company was soon to follow with a railroad in and out of Rhinelander for the lumber industry.

Rhinelander, Wisconsin tourism photo featured in a Creative City Developments case study: trail
trail

Tourism

Tourism statistics on Rhinelander, Wisconsin are thin. There is data on the county in Wisconsin that Rhinelander is located. Oneida County is the name and Rhinelander is the largest of the three main towns in the area. The county itself brought in 237 million in tourism and it is on the rise. Rhinelander uses both traditional tourism and creative city developments to create this wealth.

Some of the main, more traditional tourist activities that bring people to this region are outdoor activities like hiking, camping, boating, canoeing, and bird watching. In the winter, cross country skiing, snowshoeing, and snowmobiling. They have year round offerings for tourists.

The creative town development I would like to focus on is the Hodag. Hodag is an urban legend dating back to 1892. The Hodag is a fearsome monster that roams central Wisconsin, in the same company as the chupacabra, Bigfoot, or any other well known but impossible to photograph creature. Artist interpretations can be seen all over the city’s website and a giant statue stands in one of the town’s parks. The original description of the Hodag was reported as such:

The original description of the Hodag

“Hodag had the head of a frog, the grinning face of a giant elephant, thick, short legs set off by huge claws, the back of a dinosaur, and a long tail with spears at the end. The Hodag also had green eyes, huge fangs and two horns sprouting from its temples.”

What is very odd is this description of the Hodag greatly represents a native american myth of the “water panther” along the Lake Superior shore.

Whether the Hodag is a myth or not, Rhinelander’s love of the Hodag is not. Their chamber of commerce has an oversized statue of the Hodag. There are pictures, murals, and paintings of the Hodag throughout town.

The town’s promotion of the Hodag is what creates interest around the town. Think about it like this. Tourists have many, many options for where to stay while they explore the remote forests of Wisconsin. Much of Wisconsin is undeveloped land, so tourists have options, but the reason to go to Rhinelander over these other towns is that they are funky. Would you rather go to a normal town or a funky one?

A NORMAL TOWN OR A FUNKY ONE?

Buckle up, incoming Batman quote: “as a symbol … as a symbol I can be incorruptible, I can be everlasting.” And that is what Hodag Wisconsin has. Hodag is a long term symbol that has given its residents something to talk about and make their own. It is their creative city development they have used for over a hundred years. Just look at how they name different businesses and events in town:

What the Hodag represents

The Hodag represents prosperity, not itself but for the town. Creating a myth has bonded the people of Rhinelander, given visitors something to talk about when they return home, and created objects, like statues, representing the myth that compounds the tourism interest in the area. The Hodag as a creative city focal point has allowed the city to sustain growth, retain residents, and draw tourism. It is nothing less than a success.

Rhinelander, Wisconsin tourism photo featured in a Creative City Developments case study: Hodag statue
Rhinelander field photo, archive image
237M in tourism spending across the county

Summary

The Hodag is a myth and symbol that has united Rhinelander, Wisconsin and is their creative city development that drives tourism. Starting a myth is low cost, look at Remer, Minnesota, home of the Bigfoot, and it lasts for a long time.

Rhinelander, Wisconsin tourism photo featured in a Creative City Developments case study: tourism scene
Rhinelander / field reference

Whether or not the Hodag is real, besides the horns and the lizard-like body, the most noticeable feature is its ability to bind a town around it.

Rhinelander, Wisconsin tourism photo featured in a Creative City Developments case study: festival
Hodag Country Music Festival
Where Pueblo West sits

On the Visitor Impact Score curve

On the Visitor Impact Score curve, Rhinelander lands in the On the Map band at 67, a snapshot of how much of its raw potential is currently built for visitors.

/06 / Notable contributors

Credit where due

Explore Rhinelander

The official destination site for Rhinelander tells the Hodag discovery story and the classic physical description of the beast, and promotes the Hodag Country Festival that draws visitors to town. Source

Pioneer Park Historical Complex

Rhinelander’s local history museum keeps the legend alive through its Hodag page and ongoing preservation and celebration of the town’s signature myth. Source

Rhinelander Chamber of Commerce

The chamber maintains the oversized Hodag statue that greets visitors, a landmark documented as the town’s most recognizable roadside attraction. Source

Travel Wisconsin

The Wisconsin Department of Tourism research hub is the source behind the county visitor spending figures that show Oneida County tourism climbing into the hundreds of millions. Source

Field notes

From the margins

Old myth
The Hodag legend dates back to 1892, a monster hoax that Rhinelander has carried as its symbol for over a hundred years.
County haul
Oneida County, where Rhinelander is the largest of three main towns, brought in 237 million in tourism and it is on the rise.
Named after it
The town has stamped the Hodag on a dozen local businesses and events, from Hodag Park to the Hodag Country Festival.
/07 / Sources

How this score was derived

Read the method. The VIS framework scores eight categories, one multiplier (Unique Hook) and seven components (Web, Brand, Anchor, Downtown, Curb, Stay, Return). Online-tier scores are derived from desk research; audit-tier categories require a physical visit and shift the composite once a field trip is logged.

  1. Hodag Lake (a small public-access lake west of Rhinelander)
  2. Hodag Park (on the shores of Boom Lake in downtown Rhinelander; home to Hodag Water Ski Shows in the summer)
  3. Hodag Sno Trails (Rhinelander’s snowmobiling club)
  4. The Hodag Store
  5. 3 Hodag Country (WHDG)
  6. Hodag Farmers Market
  7. Hodag Run For Your Life (5K/10K/half marathon hosted by YMCA of the Northwoods)
  8. Hodag Lanes (bowling alley in Rhinelander)
  9. Hodag Pump & Pantry
  10. Hodag Property Management
  11. Hodag Honda
  12. Hodag BP

Image credits: Rhinelander field and archive photos via Creative City Developments, including the Hodag statue, the bike trail, and the Hodag Country Music Festival.

Find your town’s Visitor Impact Score

Creative City Developments scores the gap between what a place already has and what visitors actually experience, then helps close it. If your community has world-class assets and an under-told story, let us talk.

Request a Visitor Impact Score